Rare coins and other collectible numismatics offered for sale or auction by dealers and collectors.

Browse by Category:

  • Home
  • United States Coins
  • United States Paper Money
  • Bullion
  • Canadian Coins
  • World Coins
  • Paper Money of the World
  • Private Mint Issues
  • Ancient Coins
  • Medals, Tokens and other Exonumia
  • Stock, Bond and other Certificates
  • Numismatic Publications and Supplies
  • Sitemap
  • or by State and Town:

  • Home
  • Alabama
  • Alaska
  • Arizona
  • Arkansas
  • California
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • Delaware
  • District of Columbia
  • Florida
  • Georgia
  • Hawaii
  • Idaho
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Iowa
  • Kansas
  • Kentucky
  • Louisiana
  • Maine
  • Maryland
  • Massachusetts
  • Michigan
  • Minnesota
  • Mississippi
  • Missouri
  • Montana
  • Nebraska
  • Nevada
  • New Hampshire
  • New Jersey
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • North Carolina
  • North Dakota
  • Ohio
  • Oklahoma
  • Oregon
  • Pennsylvania
  • Rhode Island
  • Sitemap
  • South Carolina
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Utah
  • Vermont
  • Virginia
  • Washington
  • West Virginia
  • Wisconsin
  • Wyoming
  • Extra Fine Coins Storefront

    1937 U.S. Buffalo Head Nickel (Circulated)
    1937 U.S. Buffalo Head Nickel (Circulated)
    $4.00
    Sale ends in Minutes!
    #4 MERCURY HEAD AND IH ON ENDS  BONUS 2 BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS .
    #4 MERCURY HEAD AND IH ON ENDS BONUS 2 BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS .
    $10.99
    Only a few Hours Left!
    1938 D/D Buffalo Head Nickel Uncirculated PCGS MS 65 OGH D over D Beauty A1
    1938 D/D Buffalo Head Nickel Uncirculated PCGS MS 65 OGH D over D Beauty A1
    $44.15
    Sale ends in Hours!
    1938 D Buffalo Head Nickel Uncirculated PCGS MS 65 Old Rattler Holder Coin A18
    1938 D Buffalo Head Nickel Uncirculated PCGS MS 65 Old Rattler Holder Coin A18
    $11.50
    Sale ends in Hours!
    1937 Silver Buffalo Head Nickle Coin
    1937 Silver Buffalo Head Nickle Coin
    $0.99
    Sale Ends Today!
    US COIN LOT: 3 Silver Mercury Dimes, 5 Buffalo Head Nickels, 1 Unc Lincoln Cent
    US COIN LOT: 3 Silver Mercury Dimes, 5 Buffalo Head Nickels, 1 Unc Lincoln Cent
    $12.55
    Sale Ends Today!
    Lot of 13 Wartime Earlier Coins - 6 1941 Nickels - Mercury Dimes - Buffalo Head
    Lot of 13 Wartime Earlier Coins - 6 1941 Nickels - Mercury Dimes - Buffalo Head
    $10.00
    Thru Tomorrow Only!
    1913-P type 1 one BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL
    1913-P type 1 one BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL
    $12.99
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Buffalo head nickels
    Buffalo head nickels
    $3.00
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    1926 P Buffalo Head Nickel Fine
    1926 P Buffalo Head Nickel Fine
    $3.95
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Buffalo Head Nickels 1926 - 1937 Plus No Dates  Total Lot of 13
    Buffalo Head Nickels 1926 - 1937 Plus No Dates Total Lot of 13
    $0.99
    Available until Monday
    1935, 1936, 1937 Buffalo Head Nickels and 50 Wheat Cents + Extra Coins #34
    1935, 1936, 1937 Buffalo Head Nickels and 50 Wheat Cents + Extra Coins #34
    $1.48
    Available until Monday
    1937 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - NICE - LUSTER - MS UNC 70762
    1937 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - NICE - LUSTER - MS UNC 70762
    $15.00
    Available until Monday
    1927 buffalo head nickel
    1927 buffalo head nickel
    $1.50
    Available until Monday
    1921 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - VG 70069
    1921 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - VG 70069
    $4.00
    Available until Tuesday
    1936 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - AU 70540
    1936 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - AU 70540
    $4.37
    Available until Tuesday
    1937 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - AU 70542
    1937 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - AU 70542
    $4.37
    Available until Tuesday
    1936 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Fine 70552
    1936 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Fine 70552
    $3.28
    Available until Tuesday
    1937-S 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - San Francisco - FINE 70717
    1937-S 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - San Francisco - FINE 70717
    $45.00
    Available until Tuesday
    1937 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - FINE 70718
    1937 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - FINE 70718
    $0.99
    Available until Tuesday
    1913-S 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - San Francisco - GOOD 70719
    1913-S 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - San Francisco - GOOD 70719
    $27.00
    Available until Tuesday
    1915-D 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - Denver - VERY GOOD 70724
    1915-D 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - Semi Key Date - Denver - VERY GOOD 70724
    $9.00
    Available until Tuesday
    1936 UNITED STATES BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL 5¢ COIN / PCGS GRADED MINT STATE 65 ~WOW~
    1936 UNITED STATES BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL 5¢ COIN / PCGS GRADED MINT STATE 65 ~WOW~
    $11.50
    Available until Tuesday
     Indian Head Penny - One Cent & Buffalo Head Nickel - Five Cent, Lot of 8 Coins
    Indian Head Penny - One Cent & Buffalo Head Nickel - Five Cent, Lot of 8 Coins
    $5.99
    Sale ends in Hours!
    1938-D 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - NICE - LUSTER - Denver - MS UNC 70800
    1938-D 5c - Buffalo Head Nickel - NICE - LUSTER - Denver - MS UNC 70800
    $20.00
    Available until Wednesday
    VIETNAM - 1986 10 Dong UNC
    VIETNAM - 1986 10 Dong UNC "Water buffalo head" SCARCE
    $13.50
    Available until Wednesday
    1913 UNITED STATES ~TYPE II~ BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL 5¢ COIN / CHOICE EXTRA FINE
    1913 UNITED STATES ~TYPE II~ BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL 5¢ COIN / CHOICE EXTRA FINE
    $0.99
    Available until Wednesday
    1938 D UNITED STATES BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL 5¢ COIN / CH. UNCIRCULATED CONDITION!
    1938 D UNITED STATES BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL 5¢ COIN / CH. UNCIRCULATED CONDITION!
    $0.99
    Available until Wednesday
    1936 5C Buffalo Head Nickel / Double Die
    1936 5C Buffalo Head Nickel / Double Die
    $5.99
    On Sale until Thursday
    Buffalo Head Nickels 40-Coin Roll: 1935, 1936 and 1937
    Buffalo Head Nickels 40-Coin Roll: 1935, 1936 and 1937
    $10.00
    On Sale until Thursday
    1935 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B255
    1935 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B255
    $1.50
    Only a few Hours Left!
    Lot of
    Lot of "4" U.S. 1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Head Nickels ABP / AG ##NC01 (No Date)
    $0.01
    On Sale until Thursday
    1oz Copper 39mm Round .999 Fine Copper Bullion, Indian Buffalo Head Design
    1oz Copper 39mm Round .999 Fine Copper Bullion, Indian Buffalo Head Design
    $0.68
    Sale ends in Hours!
    Good 1930- Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Good 1930- Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Good 1936- Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Good 1936- Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Buffalo Head nickel (s)
    Buffalo Head nickel (s)
    $27.50
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    BUFFALO HEAD CONESTOGA WAGON 1 ozt .999 FINE SOLID SILVER ROUND
    BUFFALO HEAD CONESTOGA WAGON 1 ozt .999 FINE SOLID SILVER ROUND
    $39.99
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    1919 Buffalo Head Nickel (PCGS VF30) 3 Feathers - Nice Looking Coin
    1919 Buffalo Head Nickel (PCGS VF30) 3 Feathers - Nice Looking Coin
    $275.00
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    BUFFALO  HEAD NICKEL NECKLACE W/BEZEL & 18
    BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL NECKLACE W/BEZEL & 18" SILVER CHAIN
    $5.96
    Available until Monday
    450+ [ Rare Coin Collection Lot ] Buffalo head / Morgan Dollar / Walking Liberty
    450+ [ Rare Coin Collection Lot ] Buffalo head / Morgan Dollar / Walking Liberty
    $1,199.00
    Available until Monday
    1926 Variety 2 Buffalo Head Nickle
    1926 Variety 2 Buffalo Head Nickle
    $0.99
    On Sale until Saturday
    1914/3 Buffalo Head Nickel Rare US Coin
    1914/3 Buffalo Head Nickel Rare US Coin
    $500.00
    Available until Tuesday
    2 1928 BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS. RARE TO COME ACROSS. FAIR TO GOOD CONDITION!
    2 1928 BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS. RARE TO COME ACROSS. FAIR TO GOOD CONDITION!
    $2.99
    Available until Tuesday
    1935 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B259
    1935 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B259
    $2.75
    Available until Tuesday
    KEY DATE Coin Lot 2C:  F - VF 1926-S Buffalo Head Nickel
    KEY DATE Coin Lot 2C: F - VF 1926-S Buffalo Head Nickel
    $99.00
    Available until Tuesday
    Good 1937-D  Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Good 1937-D Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    1931-S Buffalo Head Nickel Very Fine Condition Semi-Key Date
    1931-S Buffalo Head Nickel Very Fine Condition Semi-Key Date
    $16.99
    Only a few Hours Left!
    1937 BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL
    1937 BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL
    $0.99
    Available until Tuesday
    Good 1937- Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Good 1937- Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    buffalo head nickel
    buffalo head nickel
    $50.00
    On Sale until Thursday
    1914-D Buffalo Head Nickel Very Good Condition Key Date
    1914-D Buffalo Head Nickel Very Good Condition Key Date
    $99.99
    Only a few Hours Left!
    1917-S Buffalo Head Nickel Fine Condition Semi-Key Date
    1917-S Buffalo Head Nickel Fine Condition Semi-Key Date
    $74.99
    Only a few Hours Left!
    buffalo head nickels 400 in lot old tin can indian head us nickels five cents
    buffalo head nickels 400 in lot old tin can indian head us nickels five cents
    $175.00
    On Sale until Thursday
    1936 D  Buffalo Head  Nickel
    1936 D Buffalo Head Nickel
    $2.00
    On Sale until Thursday
    1923-S, 1923-F, 1925-S, 1925 US BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS WORN & TONED  GOOD
    1923-S, 1923-F, 1925-S, 1925 US BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS WORN & TONED GOOD
    $0.99
    Available until Tuesday
    1925 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    1925 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    $0.99
    Available until Monday
    Buffalo Head Nickels
    Buffalo Head Nickels
    $5.00
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Good 1937-D Buffalo Head Nickel -Circulated-Uncertified
    Good 1937-D Buffalo Head Nickel -Circulated-Uncertified
    $1.50
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Weak Date 1924- Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Weak Date 1924- Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Weak Date 1926- Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Weak Date 1926- Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Good 1935- Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Good 1935- Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    6 Buffalo Head Nickels
    6 Buffalo Head Nickels
    $9.00
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    4 Buffalo Head Nickels
    4 Buffalo Head Nickels
    $5.00
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    Weak Date 1927- Buffalo Head  Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    Weak Date 1927- Buffalo Head Nickel-Circulated-Ungraded
    $1.79
    Sale Ends Tomorrow!
    buffalo head nickels 13 total featuring 1920 S / 1935 D / 1937 d
    buffalo head nickels 13 total featuring 1920 S / 1935 D / 1937 d
    $21.95
    Available until Monday
    1936-S- Fine Buffalo Head With Horn  Nickel
    1936-S- Fine Buffalo Head With Horn Nickel
    $1.99
    Available until Monday
    1927 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    1927 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    $0.99
    Available until Monday
    1934 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    1934 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    $0.99
    Available until Monday
    1935 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    1935 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    $0.99
    Available until Monday
    1937 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    1937 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    $0.99
    Available until Monday
    1930 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    1930 BUFFALO HEAD NICKLE
    $0.99
    Available until Monday
    1935 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B250
    1935 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B250
    $1.50
    On Sale until Friday
    1923-1937 Buffalo Head Nickels lot size 20 coins
    1923-1937 Buffalo Head Nickels lot size 20 coins
    $38.88
    Available until Monday
    GOLD BUFFALO Head Nickel  Antique WW2 World War 2 Era Rare *24 K GOLD PLATED
    GOLD BUFFALO Head Nickel Antique WW2 World War 2 Era Rare *24 K GOLD PLATED
    $3.75
    Available until Tuesday
    GOLD BUFFALO Head Nickel  Antique WW2 World War 2 Era Rare *24 KARAT GOLD PLATED
    GOLD BUFFALO Head Nickel Antique WW2 World War 2 Era Rare *24 KARAT GOLD PLATED
    $3.75
    Available until Tuesday
    22 BEAT UP BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS +1 BARBER + SF MINT COIN FREE SHIP NO RESERVE!
    22 BEAT UP BUFFALO HEAD NICKELS +1 BARBER + SF MINT COIN FREE SHIP NO RESERVE!
    $7.49
    On Sale until Saturday
    1925-S AU BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL ID#A58
    1925-S AU BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL ID#A58
    $129.97
    1937 Buffalo Head Nickel - Philadelphia Mint Issue - Nice FINE Details
    1937 Buffalo Head Nickel - Philadelphia Mint Issue - Nice FINE Details
    $3.29
    Available until Tuesday
     VF-1936-S Buffalo Head Nickel With Full Horn
    VF-1936-S Buffalo Head Nickel With Full Horn
    $2.59
    Available until Tuesday
    Very Nice 1936 Buffalo Head Nickel
    Very Nice 1936 Buffalo Head Nickel
    $1.79
    Available until Tuesday
    Weak Date 1920  Buffalo Head Nickel
    Weak Date 1920 Buffalo Head Nickel
    $2.00
    Available until Tuesday
    1936 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B258
    1936 P Old Buffalo Head Nickel B258
    $1.35
    On Sale until Friday
    1935 Buffalo Head Nickle 5 Cents - USA
    1935 Buffalo Head Nickle 5 Cents - USA
    $0.80
    On Sale until Saturday
    1919 D BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL VG 2196F
    1919 D BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL VG 2196F
    $24.99
    On Sale until Saturday
    1921 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL AG GOOD 2161F
    1921 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL AG GOOD 2161F
    $29.00
    On Sale until Saturday
    1927 P BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL XF 2195F
    1927 P BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL XF 2195F
    $11.99
    On Sale until Saturday
    1930 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL XF 2160F
    1930 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL XF 2160F
    $12.00
    On Sale until Saturday
    1931 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL VF 2158F
    1931 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL VF 2158F
    $16.00
    On Sale until Saturday
    1931 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL VF 2159F
    1931 S BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL VF 2159F
    $16.00
    On Sale until Saturday
    1934 D BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL XF 2157F
    1934 D BUFFALO HEAD NICKEL XF 2157F
    $16.00
    On Sale until Saturday
    Lot of 4 Buffalo head Nickels.1920, 1928, 1936, 1936D.
    Lot of 4 Buffalo head Nickels.1920, 1928, 1936, 1936D.
    $5.00
    Available until Wednesday
    GOLD BUFFALO Head Nickel Old Antique WW 2 World War 2 Era Rare *24 K GOLD PLATED
    GOLD BUFFALO Head Nickel Old Antique WW 2 World War 2 Era Rare *24 K GOLD PLATED
    $3.90
    On Sale until Thursday
    1920 Buffalo Head Nickel 5 Cents - USA
    1920 Buffalo Head Nickel 5 Cents - USA
    $0.80
    On Sale until Thursday
    1919 Indian / Buffalo Head Nickel
    1919 Indian / Buffalo Head Nickel
    $5.00
    On Sale until Thursday
    Five buffalo head nickles on hair clasp
    Five buffalo head nickles on hair clasp
    $3.00
    Only a few Hours Left!
    1930-S-Nice Buffalo Head Nickel
    1930-S-Nice Buffalo Head Nickel
    $2.00
    On Sale until Thursday
    Don't find EXACTLY what you need?
    Save a search and elect to have it emailed- FREE! ...